Two boxes, one clear decision
Both the Box of Evergreens and the Box of Cedar from Lynch Creek Farm deliver roughly 20 pounds of fresh, locally collected Washington greenery. The choice comes down to what you're making. The Box of Evergreens gives you a mix of noble fir, incense cedar, and white pine, so you get variety in color, texture, and needle length. The Box of Cedar is a single-species box of Western Red Cedar, which means consistent, fragrant branches that are easy to work with in bulk.
If your project calls for visual contrast and different textures, the mixed box is the stronger pick. If you want one uniform green for garlands, swags, or a large arrangement where cedar's fragrance is the star, the cedar box makes more sense.
What's actually in each box
- Box of Evergreens: Approximately 14 lbs of noble fir in 6"–24" pieces, 3 lbs of incense cedar in 6"–18" pieces, and 3 lbs of white pine in 6"–12" pieces. Total weight is about 20 lbs. The mix gives you long fir branches for structure, cedar for fragrance, and pine for soft texture.
- Box of Cedar: Approximately 20 lbs of Western Red Cedar branches in an assortment of lengths from 6" to 18". This is a single-species box, so every branch shares the same color and needle style.
Fragrance and look: mixed vs. uniform
The Box of Evergreens brings three distinct fragrances and textures together. Noble fir has a classic, crisp evergreen scent and stiff branches that hold their shape in arrangements. Incense cedar adds a deeper, woodsy note, and white pine contributes soft, flexible needles that fill gaps nicely. The visual result is a natural, varied look with different shades of green and different needle lengths.
The Box of Cedar is all Western Red Cedar, which has a strong, sweet, and slightly spicy fragrance. The branches are uniform in color and texture, making them ideal when you want a clean, consistent look—think a long garland or a simple vase display where the cedar itself is the feature. If you prefer a single, recognizable scent and a cohesive green, cedar is the straightforward choice.
Key details for your decision
- Box of Evergreens: Box of Evergreens contains approximately 14 lbs of noble fir (6"–24" pieces), 3 lbs of incense cedar (6"–18" pieces), and 3 lbs of white pine (6"–12" pieces); total weight about 20 lbs. The three-species mix gives you different textures and colors for arrangements, mantels, and DIY projects that benefit from variety.

Box of Evergreens - Box of Cedar: Box of Cedar contains approximately 20 lbs of Western Red Cedar branches in an assortment of lengths from 6" to 18". A single-species box provides uniform branches for projects where consistency and cedar's strong fragrance are the priority.

Box of Cedar
How to match the box to your project
For a mixed evergreen arrangement where you want height, contrast, and a blend of scents, the Box of Evergreens is the better fit. The noble fir pieces are long enough (up to 24") to serve as a base, while the cedar and pine add fullness and aroma. This box also suits tablescapes, mantel garlands, and planters where you want a natural, gathered look.
For a project that calls for one type of green—like a cedar garland, a simple bundle in a vase, or a wreath base—the Box of Cedar keeps things simple. The 6"–18" lengths are versatile for many crafts, and the strong cedar scent carries well indoors. If you plan to make multiple items that should look consistent, cedar's uniformity is an advantage.
Longevity and care: what to expect
Both boxes share the same stated longevity: approximately 3 weeks indoors and 4–6 weeks outdoors when spritzed with water every 2–3 days. That care guidance comes directly from the product information. Keep in mind that indoor heat and dry air will shorten that window, so misting regularly is the main way to keep either box looking fresh. Neither product record includes specific temperature or humidity limits, so use your judgment based on your space.
Care and longevity at a glance
- Box of Evergreens: Longevity: approximately 3 weeks indoors and 4–6 weeks outdoors when spritzed with water every 2–3 days. This tells you how long you can expect the mixed greens to last with basic misting, helping you plan your decorating timeline.
- Box of Cedar: Longevity: approximately 3 weeks indoors and 4–6 weeks outdoors when spritzed with water every 2–3 days. Cedar shares the same care window, so you can compare the two boxes on equal footing for project scheduling.
Price and value: what the numbers say
At the catalog prices shown, the Box of Evergreens is listed at $59.37 (compare at $89.95) and the Box of Cedar at $58.47 (compare at $89.95). The difference is less than a dollar, so price alone shouldn't decide it. Both boxes weigh about 20 pounds, but the Evergreens box splits that weight across three species, while the Cedar box is all one type. If you want maximum variety for the same weight, the mixed box delivers more visual and textural range. If you specifically need cedar, the cedar box is the direct route.
What the supplied information doesn't cover
The product records do not include any safety warnings, compatibility notes, or customization options for either box. There's also no information about lead times or delivery constraints beyond what's stated here. If you need specific assurances about shipping or handling, check the store's current policies before ordering. Neither box lists a variant beyond Standard, so you won't be choosing between sizes or options.
A practical way to decide
Ask yourself one question: do you want variety or uniformity? If you're building mixed arrangements, filling multiple containers with different textures, or want a blend of fragrances, choose the Box of Evergreens. If you're making a cedar-focused project—garlands, swags, or simple vase displays—or you just love the smell of cedar, choose the Box of Cedar. Both arrive fresh from the Cascade and Olympic foothills, both need misting every 2–3 days, and both give you about 20 pounds of greenery to work with. With nearly identical pricing, the decision is about the material, not the cost.



